Plot vs. Spontaneity




While reading On Writing, Stephen King challenged my process of writing, “Plot is, I think, the good writer’s last resort and the dullard’s first choice.”  Damn.  Apparently, I've been writing pedantic stories.  Doesn't bode well for a successful career.  

By nature, I am a control freak and prefer to plan everything out, albeit day trips, vacations or my novel.   Back in November 2010, when I embarked on the insane NaNoWriMo challenge, I created an outline of my entire mystery novel.  Being the first time I’d ever written anything so long, I felt safer with a plan.  As I wrote, my story deviated from the plan.  I listened to the story, letting it lead the way, but still knew what I wanted to happen in the story. 

Of course you will find many writers split on this topic.  Some contradictory advice I’ve read says writing without an outlined plot leads to bird-walk writing.  Presenting you with the task of cutting large parts of your prose because it doesn't having anything to do with the story. 

King on the other hand believes stories “pretty much make themselves.  The job of the writer is to give them a place to grow (and to transcribe them, of course.”  He puts his characters into a situation and allows them to work out the solution on their own with no input from him. 

He admits some of his novels were written based off a plot outline, but he really tries to avoid these situations as much as possible.  Rose Madder and Insomnia, products of plotting, were “stiff, trying-to-hard novels” he feels.  Personally, I really enjoyed Rose Madder.

 Stories are fossils, according to King.  They are found, not created.  The stories come to a writer through dreams or everyday observations, but they already exist.  “And none of the story’s details and incidents proceeded from plot; they were organic, each arising naturally from the initial situation, each an uncovered part of the fossil.” 

So, I’m left to mull over my writing process.  The only way I can really decide between plotting and spontaneity is to give the latter a try.  I know removing the safety net of an outlined plot will produce an eye twitch or two, but what have I got to lose? 

Do you prefer plotting or spontaneity when writing?    

Comments

Michael Offutt, Phantom Reader said…
You know, I've only liked a handful of Stephen King stories so I'm going to say that although Mr. King's formula works for 99 percent of everyone, that 1 percent (me in the role of a reader) prefers well-plotted novels. So although this is excellent advice, you're bound to alienate some readers who really like this kind of story by pursuing this. But if you sell ten books to one then it's all about profit right? I say personally, write whatever you want to and hope it sells. If you're a plotter...please PLOT and I'll read it. If not...sell to the other nine people and I won't read it. Simple as that.
February 28, 2011 at 12:19 PM
Laura M. Campbell said…
At this point, I'm open to experimentation. My style and process look like a big lump a clay. It needs to be thrown in the wheel, shaping it with different techniques until I form my true voice. I'll never know if it works until I try.
March 1, 2011 at 7:36 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

L is for Location, Location, Location

Image
Source Readers look to novels to escape reality. An author’s words take them to distant lands. But a well-described location can do more than just take the reader on a trip away from home. It plays an important role in creating atmosphere and describing characters. The strength of location in a story transforms the setting into another character. Characters and setting rely heavily on one another not only to create images in the minds of readers, but also to describe each other.  A character reveals information about a setting. Their traits lead them to specific towns, cities, bars, schools, etc. A well-developed character personality can create the milieu. An uptight individual probably lives in a very neat and organized apartment. A character concerned with the environment might have a vegetable garden planted in the back with a recycling bin and compost heap. A young, single girl might feel stuck in family-oriented suburbia. Now, the...
Read more

Insecure Writer's Support Group:Overwhelmed

Image
Source My road trip to Boston at the end of August arrived just in time to relieve me from the constant head banging on the wall between me and my writing, blogging and freelance career. The permanent knot on my forehead, bald patches and a jaw that clicks every time I open my mouth has transformed me into a monster you might catch in the dark alleyways of Gotham City. I overdosed on advice in writing magazines, on writing-related websites and blogs. If you peek through the windows, you catch me wandering around the house strung out, too jittery to sit down at my laptop. As an information junkie, I hoarded writing techniques, strategies and prompts. I shoved them into every available space in my writing toolbox, reminding me of an overly prepared-style of packing. Overstuffed. I would sit on the lid to force it shut if it weren’t for the motivational quotes spilling over the sides keeping me from latching the damn thing. Then I come across an article contradicting th...
Read more

E is for Erasure Poetry

Image
rattle.com April is National Poetry Month . So, I thought I'd give  erasure poetry  a try. I chose an article about dating and race in The Philadelphia Inquirer .  Reading through the article, I underlined words that caught my eye. Then, I created a poem and title from my found words. Unfortunately, it was easier to type the words than scan the article. Enjoy! Talk About Dating First contact          Attitudes affect the messages Cut off from the real world          See the imbalance Healthy partners          Work together, no exclusions
Read more